Spoken HistoryReal history. Real evidence.
133 B.C. to A.D. 160

Roman Sling Bullets: Insults Cast in Lead

Roman Sling BulletsSling BulletGlandesGlansLead Sling BulletRoman Slingers

A lump of lead, about 4.5 centimetres long. It weighs 60 grams. On one side, a thunderbolt. On the other, raised letters: the number of a legion, the eleventh, and two words. DIVOM IVLIVM. The deified Julius. It was found at Perugia, in Italy. There, in the winter of 41 to 40 B.C., the young Octavian, the future Augustus, was starving out an army of his rivals. His side, scholars think, slung bullets like this one at the town. And this is one of the polite ones.

The Perusine bullet L XI / DIVOM IVLIVM with its thunderbolt, as photographed for Zangemeister's corpus (Ephemeris Epigraphica VI, 1885, plate IX 7), with our labels. The Munich example weighs 60 grams.
The Perusine bullet L XI / DIVOM IVLIVM with its thunderbolt, as photographed for Zangemeister's corpus (Ephemeris Epigraphica VI, 1885, plate IX 7), with our labels. The Munich example weighs 60 grams.Original animation, Spoken History
Animated map: Perusia, modern Perugia, where Octavian besieged Lucius Antonius in the winter of 41 to 40 B.C. Modern coastline.
Animated map: Perusia, modern Perugia, where Octavian besieged Lucius Antonius in the winter of 41 to 40 B.C. Modern coastline.Original animation, Spoken History. Map data (where shown): Natural Earth, public domain

Glandes. Roman sling bullets. Today we're asking what these bullets were, what has been dug up, and what the texts really say. Because some of these little lumps of lead carry words. Messages, slung at the enemy.

Roman slingers on Trajan's Column, A.D. 113 (scene LXVI), in Conrad Cichorius's plate of 1896. They carry stones in a fold of the cloak, not lead bullets.
Roman slingers on Trajan's Column, A.D. 113 (scene LXVI), in Conrad Cichorius's plate of 1896. They carry stones in a fold of the cloak, not lead bullets.Slingers on Trajan's Column, A.D. 113 (scene LXVI). Plate by Conrad Cichorius, 1896. Public domain

What is a glans?

So, what is a glans? The Latin word means an acorn. The great Latin dictionary of Lewis and Short calls the missile an acorn-shaped ball of lead or clay, hurled at the enemy. Many Roman ones look more like an almond or a lemon, pointed at both ends. These, found together in England, weigh from about 67 to 123 grams. They were cast. Molten lead went into a two-part mould. Any letters were cut backwards into the mould, so they came out raised and readable on the bullet. And the army cast them itself. In Africa, in 46 B.C., the unknown author of the African War writes that Caesar's army set up smithies, cast sling bullets, and sent to Sicily for lead. The weapon that threw them was simple. Two cords and a pouch. The late Roman writer Vegetius says slings were made of flax or of hair.

Animation: three published bullets drawn to scale with each other, two from a group found together in England (Portable Antiquities Scheme) and the Perusine L XI bullet (Zangemeister n. 77).
Animation: three published bullets drawn to scale with each other, two from a group found together in England (Portable Antiquities Scheme) and the Perusine L XI bullet (Zangemeister n. 77).Original animation, Spoken History
Roman lead sling bullets of the mid-1st century A.D., part of a group of twelve found together in England. This one weighs 67.3 grams.
Roman lead sling bullets of the mid-1st century A.D., part of a group of twelve found together in England. This one weighs 67.3 grams.Roman lead sling bullet, mid-1st century A.D., found in England. Portable Antiquities Scheme, PUBLIC-07BA1C. Photo: Roger Thomas, CC BY 2.0
Animation, a schematic of casting as Zangemeister reads it from the raised letters and a surviving clay mould half: letters cut backwards into a two-part mould, lead poured in, the letters come out readable.
Animation, a schematic of casting as Zangemeister reads it from the raised letters and a surviving clay mould half: letters cut backwards into a two-part mould, lead poured in, the letters come out readable.Original animation, Spoken History
Animated map: Caesar's camp at Ruspina, 46 B.C., where his army cast sling bullets and asked Sicily for lead (Bellum Africum 20).
Animated map: Caesar's camp at Ruspina, 46 B.C., where his army cast sling bullets and asked Sicily for lead (Bellum Africum 20).Original animation, Spoken History. Map data (where shown): Natural Earth, public domain
Animation, a schematic slinger: two cords and a pouch. No Roman sling survives that we could check; Vegetius says slings were made of flax or of hair.
Animation, a schematic slinger: two cords and a pouch. No Roman sling survives that we could check; Vegetius says slings were made of flax or of hair.Original animation, Spoken History

The siege of Perusia

Back to Perugia. Ancient Perusia, a town on a hill in Etruria. In 41 B.C., Mark Antony's brother Lucius, who was consul that year, and Antony's wife Fulvia took up arms against Octavian. Lucius ended up shut inside Perusia. The historian Appian, writing nearly two centuries later, says Octavian ringed the hill with a ditch 30 feet deep and 30 wide, and a wall with 1,500 wooden towers. Inside, the food ran out. Appian says the slaves were refused rations and ate grass, and the dead were buried in long trenches, so the enemy would not see how many there were. When the besieged tried to break out, he says, they fought from their siege towers with stones, arrows, and leaden balls.

Perugia today: the hill town of ancient Perusia.
Perugia today: the hill town of ancient Perusia.Perugia today: the town walls on the hill. Photo: Kurraudea, CC BY-SA 3.0
Mark Antony and Octavian on one silver denarius, struck in 41 B.C., the year the war at Perusia began.
Mark Antony and Octavian on one silver denarius, struck in 41 B.C., the year the war at Perusia began.Denarius of Mark Antony and Octavian, 41 B.C., Ephesus mint. Photo: Classical Numismatic Group, CC BY-SA 2.5
Animation, a schematic plan after Appian (Civil Wars 5.33 to 36): Octavian's ditch and wall with towers around the hill, the arms to the Tiber, the famine and the break-out. Not a survey of the site.
Animation, a schematic plan after Appian (Civil Wars 5.33 to 36): Octavian's ditch and wall with towers around the hill, the arms to the Tiber, the famine and the break-out. Not a survey of the site.Original animation, Spoken History

Bullets that talk back

And the bullets from that siege talk back. In 1885, the German scholar Karl Zangemeister published the inscribed Latin sling bullets known in his day. Perusia has its own chapter, and its own photographic plates. Most, he argued, came from Octavian's side. Some carry a commander: CAESAR IMP, Caesar, general. That is Octavian, who used his adoptive father's name. Some name a legion and an officer. L XII. SCAEVA PR PIL: legion 12, Scaeva, chief centurion. And some carry a message. One reads: ESVREIS ET ME CELAS. You're starving, and you're hiding it from me. Another was scratched by hand into the finished bullet. Bald Lucius Antonius, you're done for, by Gaius Caesar's victory. Then there are the ones I can't read out. One aims at Fulvia's body. One, from Lucius's side, aims at Octavian's backside. Parts of those words are modern restorations, but the meaning is plain. And it wasn't only the soldiers. The poet Martial, more than a century later, quotes six verses that he says Augustus himself wrote about Fulvia. They are just as crude.

Photographs from Zangemeister's plates with his readings: CAESAR IMP (n. 63) and L XII SCAEVA PR PIL (n. 79).
Photographs from Zangemeister's plates with his readings: CAESAR IMP (n. 63) and L XII SCAEVA PR PIL (n. 79).Original animation, Spoken History
ESVREIS ET ME CELAS, “you're starving, and you're hiding it from me”: a Perusine bullet in Zangemeister's plate X 13 (1885).
ESVREIS ET ME CELAS, “you're starving, and you're hiding it from me”: a Perusine bullet in Zangemeister's plate X 13 (1885).Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate X 13 (ESVREIS ET ME CELAS). Public domain; scan Internet Archive
Two messages from the siege: ESVREIS ET ME CELAS (n. 84) and the hand-scratched L ANTONI CALVE PERISTI / C CAESARVS VICTORIA (n. 64).
Two messages from the siege: ESVREIS ET ME CELAS (n. 84) and the hand-scratched L ANTONI CALVE PERISTI / C CAESARVS VICTORIA (n. 64).Original animation, Spoken History
Animation: bullets attributed by Zangemeister to each side. The obscene ones are inked out; square brackets mark letters restored by modern editors.
Animation: bullets attributed by Zangemeister to each side. The obscene ones are inked out; square brackets mark letters restored by modern editors.Original animation, Spoken History
Martial, Epigrams 11.20, about A.D. 96: he quotes six crude verses that he says Augustus wrote about Fulvia. Not read out here.
Martial, Epigrams 11.20, about A.D. 96: he quotes six crude verses that he says Augustus wrote about Fulvia. Not read out here.Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? One bullet from the siege of Perusia taunts the starving town: ESVREIS ET ME CELAS, “you're starving, and you're hiding it from me” (Zangemeister 1885, n. 84). Appian says the slaves inside were refused food and ate grass.

Three hundred at the altar? A dispute

Perusia gave in to hunger early in 40 B.C. Then comes the darkest story. Suetonius writes that some say three hundred prisoners were picked out and sacrificed, on the Ides of March, at an altar to the deified Julius. Cassius Dio tells it too, as a story that goes around. Appian and Velleius, who both describe the end of the siege, don't mention it. Zangemeister linked the eleventh legion's bullet, DIVOM IVLIVM, to that story. But the bullet only names the legion and the god. Whether it called for revenge, and whether the sacrifice happened at all, we don't know.

Animation: who tells the story of three hundred sacrificed at the altar of the deified Julius, and when. Suetonius and Cassius Dio report it as hearsay; Appian and Velleius do not tell it.
Animation: who tells the story of three hundred sacrificed at the altar of the deified Julius, and when. Suetonius and Cassius Dio report it as hearsay; Appian and Velleius do not tell it.Original animation, Spoken History
Plate IX of Zangemeister's corpus (1885): bullets from Perusia, among them L XI DIVOM IVLIVM (7) and L XII SCAEVA (5).
Plate IX of Zangemeister's corpus (1885): bullets from Perusia, among them L XI DIVOM IVLIVM (7) and L XII SCAEVA (5).Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate IX, Perusia. Public domain; scan Internet Archive

The forger of Ascoli

There's a catch with inscribed bullets. Collectors wanted them. And where there's a market, there's a forger. From about 1860, a man in Ascoli, Giuseppe Vincenzini, took genuine, blank ancient bullets and hammered them into carved wooden dies, putting new words into old lead. A French scholar published more than 600 of them as genuine. In 1877, Vincenzini confessed to Zangemeister, in front of two witnesses. Zangemeister also records a boast. Vincenzini once bought an inscribed bullet from a countryman, sure it was ancient. Later he realised the inscription was his own work. How do you tell? A real inscription was cast with the bullet. The forger's letters were struck into lead that had already corroded, with sharp edges and angular round letters. And real bullets were mostly blank. At Ascoli, besieged by Rome in the Social War, Zangemeister and a local colleague dug for three days in 1877. 238 bullets. 2 had writing.

Roman lead sling bullets, one with a legion's name. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg.
Roman lead sling bullets, one with a legion's name. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg.Roman lead sling bullets, one with a legion's name. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg. Photo: Wolfgang Sauber, CC BY-SA 3.0
Animation, as Zangemeister recorded the method in 1885: genuine letters were cast with the bullet; the forger struck letters into old, blank, already corroded bullets with carved wooden dies.
Animation, as Zangemeister recorded the method in 1885: genuine letters were cast with the bullet; the forger struck letters into old, blank, already corroded bullets with carved wooden dies.Original animation, Spoken History
Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), page 93: the forger Vincenzini was once deceived by his own handiwork. Our translation.
Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), page 93: the forger Vincenzini was once deceived by his own handiwork. Our translation.Original animation, Spoken History
Animation: the 238 bullets dug up at Ascoli in three days in September 1877; two had writing (Zangemeister 1885).
Animation: the 238 bullets dug up at Ascoli in three days in September 1877; two had writing (Zangemeister 1885).Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? The forger Giuseppe Vincenzini, who stamped new inscriptions into genuine blank Roman bullets, once boasted that he had bought a bullet from a countryman as genuine and later realised the inscription was his own work (Zangemeister 1885, p. 93).

Did lead melt in flight?

So how good was a lead bullet? The Romans had an odd idea about that. Lucretius, Virgil, Ovid and Seneca all write that a lead bullet heats up in flight. Some say it melts. It doesn't. In tests for the Royal Armouries in the 1990s, Thom Richardson measured slung bullets at about 30 metres a second. At that speed, by our own calculation, the air warms the lead by less than 1 degree. Lead melts at about 327 °C. What lead did do was fly further. In the same tests, 40-gram lead bullets went about 145 metres on average. Stones, about 80 to 90. Richardson himself warns that he never learned the sling in a culture that used it. Skilled slingers may have done better. Or the old claims of range may be exaggerated.

Animation: the poets' belief against the measured speed (Richardson 1998), the warming at that speed (our calculation) and the melting point of lead (Royal Society of Chemistry).
Animation: the poets' belief against the measured speed (Richardson 1998), the warming at that speed (our calculation) and the melting point of lead (Royal Society of Chemistry).Original animation, Spoken History
Animation, to scale: average and best ranges in Thom Richardson's tests with a replica of the ancient Lahun sling (Royal Armouries Yearbook 3, 1998).
Animation, to scale: average and best ranges in Thom Richardson's tests with a replica of the ancient Lahun sling (Royal Armouries Yearbook 3, 1998).Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? Lucretius, Virgil, Ovid and Seneca believed that a lead sling bullet heats up or melts in flight. At the speeds measured by Thom Richardson, about thirty metres a second, the air warms it by less than one degree (our calculation); lead melts at about 327 degrees Celsius.

When a bullet hit

And when one hit? The Roman writer Celsus, in the first century A.D., explains what to do with a lead bullet that has broken the skin and lodged inside. Open the wound wider, he says, and draw it out with forceps, the way it went in.

Animation, a diagram of Celsus's instructions (On Medicine 7.5.4, tr. Spencer): widen the wound and draw the bullet out with forceps the way it went in. Not a picture of a real wound.
Animation, a diagram of Celsus's instructions (On Medicine 7.5.4, tr. Spencer): widen the wound and draw the bullet out with forceps the way it went in. Not a picture of a real wound.Original animation, Spoken History

Burnswark Hill, Scotland

Now, a hill in Scotland. Burnswark, in Dumfriesshire, north of the line of Hadrian's Wall. A flat-topped hill, ringed by the ramparts of an Iron Age fort. And on its slopes, two Roman camps. One to the south, one to the north. In 1898, excavators found 67 lead sling bullets here. 20 lay at one gateway of the hillfort, 12 at another. By the 1970s the count stood at 133. The archaeologist George Jobey called that unique in Britain. More recently, a team led by John Reid swept the hill with metal detectors. They found nearly 700 more signals that looked like lead sling bullets, most of them along the southern rampart. Reid traces the barrage along about half a kilometre of it. In two test trenches in 2015, 17 of the 18 lead signals turned out to be Roman bullets. Some of the bullets are small, many under 20 grams, with a hole drilled about 5 millimetres wide. When the team slung copies, they buzzed in flight, Reid writes, like an agitated wasp. He thinks they were meant to frighten. That's his team's hypothesis. And Richardson notes that a good cast whirrs anyway, with any kind of missile.

Animated map: Burnswark Hill in Dumfriesshire, north of the line of Hadrian's Wall (approximate). Modern coastline.
Animated map: Burnswark Hill in Dumfriesshire, north of the line of Hadrian's Wall (approximate). Modern coastline.Original animation, Spoken History. Map data (where shown): Natural Earth, public domain
Burnswark Hill from the east: the hillfort on the summit, Roman camps to the south (left) and north (right).
Burnswark Hill from the east: the hillfort on the summit, Roman camps to the south (left) and north (right).Burnswark Hill from the east: the hillfort on the summit, Roman camps to the south (left) and north (right). Photo: Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0
Animation, a schematic plan after Jobey (1978) and Reid (2016, 2019): the hillfort, the two Roman camps, the 1898 finds at two gateways and the spread of the detector signals. Shapes and dots are not surveyed.
Animation, a schematic plan after Jobey (1978) and Reid (2016, 2019): the hillfort, the two Roman camps, the 1898 finds at two gateways and the spread of the detector signals. Shapes and dots are not surveyed.Original animation, Spoken History
Four drilled lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill.
Four drilled lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill.Four drilled lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill. Photo: Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0
Animation: a drilled bullet, enlarged. John Reid's team heard them buzz in flight and suggests they were meant to frighten; Thom Richardson notes that a good cast whirrs with any missile.
Animation: a drilled bullet, enlarged. John Reid's team heard them buzz in flight and suggests they were meant to frighten; Thom Richardson notes that a good cast whirrs with any missile.Original animation, Spoken History

Siege or firing range?

So what happened at Burnswark? The early excavators saw a siege. In 1978, George Jobey argued for a training ground. A field school, where the army practised building camps and attacking with slings, bows and artillery. A key point: the rampart was already ruined when the bullets fell. Reid's team confirmed that. Jobey had one quibble with his own theory. There was, he wrote, some laxity in the retrieval of re-usable ammunition. Reid and his colleague Andrew Nicholson read it the other way. A barrage this big looks to them like a real assault, a show of force, perhaps at the start of the Roman advance into Scotland around A.D. 140. The title of their own paper ends with a question mark. Siege or firing range? The evidence has not settled it.

The south Roman camp at Burnswark and its mounds.
The south Roman camp at Burnswark and its mounds.The south Roman camp and its mounds, Burnswark Hill. Photo: Lynne Kirton, CC BY-SA 2.0
The two readings of Burnswark: a training ground (George Jobey, 1978) or a real assault (John Reid and Andrew Nicholson, 2019). The evidence has not settled it.
The two readings of Burnswark: a training ground (George Jobey, 1978) or a real assault (John Reid and Andrew Nicholson, 2019). The evidence has not settled it.Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? George Jobey, who argued that Burnswark was a Roman training ground, admitted one problem with his own theory: there was “some laxity in the retrieval of re-usable ammunition” (Jobey 1978).

What we really have

So, what do we really have? Thousands of real bullets, most of them blank. A small share with words: commanders, legions, jokes and threats. Texts that say the army cast them, surgeons cut them out, and poets thought they melted. What we don't have: how many Roman soldiers carried a sling, or the full story of what happened at Burnswark.

What the evidence gives us, and what it does not.
What the evidence gives us, and what it does not.Original animation, Spoken History
Lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill, Burnswark Project 2015 to 2017: lemon-shaped, acorn-shaped and drilled.
Lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill, Burnswark Project 2015 to 2017: lemon-shaped, acorn-shaped and drilled.Lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill, Burnswark Project 2015 to 2017. Photo: John H. Reid, Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0

Verdict, and what comes next

So that's the Roman sling bullet. A lump of lead you could close your hand around. And now and then, a message.

Animation: the dated evidence in this video on one time axis. Burnswark's date is a proposal.
Animation: the dated evidence in this video on one time axis. Burnswark's date is a proposal.Original animation, Spoken History

Questions for you: Burnswark: a real assault, or a firing range with sloppy clean-up? The drilled bullets: made to frighten, or is the buzz just a side effect? And what next: the Roman helmets, or the scutum?

Over to you

Burnswark: a real assault, or a firing range with sloppy clean-up? The drilled bullets: made to frighten, or is the buzz just a side effect? What next: the Roman helmets, or the scutum?

Prefer to watch? The video on YouTube covers the same story with the full animations. Jump to a part:

  • 0:00 A bullet from Perusia, 41 to 40 B.C.
  • 1:16 What is a glans?
  • 2:14 The siege of Perusia
  • 3:03 Bullets that talk back
  • 4:27 Three hundred at the altar? A dispute
  • 5:07 The forger of Ascoli
  • 6:19 Did lead melt in flight?
  • 7:15 When a bullet hit
  • 7:32 Burnswark Hill, Scotland
  • 8:55 Siege or firing range?
  • 9:48 What we really have
  • 10:12 Verdict, and what comes next

Quick answers

What is a Roman sling bullet called?

A glans, plural glandes. The Latin word means an acorn, and the Latin dictionary of Lewis and Short calls the missile an acorn-shaped ball of lead or clay, hurled at the enemy. Many Roman ones look more like an almond or a lemon, pointed at both ends.

What do the inscriptions on Roman sling bullets say?

Bullets from Octavian's siege of Perusia in 41 to 40 B.C., published by Karl Zangemeister in 1885, name commanders such as Caesar, general, and legions and officers such as legion twelve and Scaeva, chief centurion. Some carry messages, like You're starving, and you're hiding it from me, and some are obscene insults aimed at Fulvia or Octavian.

How were lead sling bullets made?

They were cast. Molten lead went into a two-part mould, and any letters were cut backwards into the mould so they came out raised and readable on the bullet. The anonymous author of the African War says Caesar's army set up smithies, cast sling bullets and sent to Sicily for lead in 46 B.C.

Did Roman lead sling bullets melt in flight?

No. Lucretius, Virgil, Ovid and Seneca wrote that a lead bullet heats up in flight, and some said it melts. Thom Richardson measured slung bullets at about thirty metres a second for the Royal Armouries; by our own calculation the air warms the lead by less than one degree at that speed, and lead melts at about 327 degrees Celsius.

What happened at Burnswark Hill?

By the 1970s excavators had found 133 lead sling bullets there, and a later metal-detector survey led by John Reid found nearly 700 more signals. George Jobey argued in 1978 for a Roman training ground; Reid and Andrew Nicholson read it as a real assault, perhaps around A.D. 140. The evidence has not settled it.

Where it happened

  • Perugia (ancient Perusia), Italy (41 B.C.): Octavian besieged Lucius Antonius here in the winter of 41 to 40 B.C.; inscribed lead sling bullets from the siege were published by Zangemeister in 1885.
  • Burnswark Hill, Dumfriesshire, Scotland (A.D. 140): An Iron Age hillfort between two Roman camps; 133 lead sling bullets known by the 1970s and nearly 700 more detected since. Siege or training ground is debated; the date is a proposal.
  • Ascoli Piceno (ancient Asculum), Italy (89 B.C.): Besieged by Rome in the Social War, 90 to 89 B.C.; Zangemeister dug up 238 bullets here in 1877, two with writing. Home of the forger Giuseppe Vincenzini.
  • Ruspina (near Monastir), Tunisia (46 B.C.): Caesar's camp in 46 B.C., where his army cast sling bullets and asked Sicily for lead (Bellum Africum 20).

Sources

Ancient writers and modern work

Everything below was read on 2026-11-14 or 2026-11-15 at the address given. Verbatim excerpts and notes are in `research/ancient-texts.md`,

`research/inscribed-glandes.md` and `research/burnswark-ballistics.md`. Each line says what the source supports in the video.

Tags used in `claims.md`: A ancient testimony, E excavated or museum evidence, M modern scholarship, D disputed and hedged, I our illustration.

The corpus of inscribed bullets (main source for the Perusia section)

  • **K. Zangemeister, *Glandes plumbeae latine inscriptae*, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (Rome and Berlin, 1885).** Full text (OCR) and the heliotype
  • plates of the University of Toronto copy at the Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/ephemerisepigrap06deutuoft (text file

    `ephemerisepigrap06deutuoft_djvu.txt`; plates = scan leaves n212, n214, n216). Read in full for the Perusine chapter (nos. 52 to 106), the

    Asculum chapter, the preface on casting, and the chapter on forgeries (pp. 88 to 97). Key passages were checked by us in the OCR text, not only

    by the research notes:

    - n. 77, plate IX 7: L XI / DIVOM / IVLIVM with a thunderbolt; the Munich example weighs 60 g, length 0.044 m; one example found at Perugia;

    "lectio omnino certa"; Zangemeister links it to Suetonius Aug. 15 and adds "ulciscamur vel simile quid" (his supplement).

    - n. 63 CAESAR IMP (plate VIII 6); n. 79 L XII SCAEVA PR PIL (plate IX 5); n. 84 ESVREIS ET ME CELAS (plate X 13), "i. e. obsidentes";

    n. 64 L ANTONI CALVE PERISTI / C CAESARVS VICTORIA, scratched in cursive after casting (plate IX 1); n. 56 FVLVIAE [LA]NDICAM PETO

    (restored; Caesarian side); n. 58 PET[O] OCTAVIA[NI] CVLVM (restored; Antonian side); nos. 61 and 62 OCTAVI LAXE (Antonian); n. 52 M ANT IMP.

    - Attribution: "longe plures Caesarianis" (most from Octavian's side).

    - Casting: two-part moulds ("Formae binis ex partibus"); letters cut reversed into the mould and cast with the bullet; a clay mould half from

    Phanagoria.

    - Asculum: three days of digging in September 1877 with G. Gabrielli, 238 bullets, 2 inscribed; 235 weighed, mean 47.13 g; about 5,000 dug

    out earlier at the same spot; the siege began probably in 664 AUC and the town fell at the end of 665 (90 to 89 B.C.), Cn. Pompeius Strabo.

    - Forger: Giuseppe Vincenzini of Ascoli, stamping from about 1860, in quantity from 1874; method (blank ancient bullets hammered into carved

    box or service-wood dies); Desjardins published "plus sescentas" (p. 91); confession at Ascoli on 16 September 1877 before two witnesses (p. 94);

    Vincenzini's boast that he once bought a bullet "a rustico quodam" as genuine and later found it bore his own inscription (p. 93); the tells

    of a struck inscription (letters later than the corrosion, sharp edges, angular round letters, words cut short on a whole bullet).

    - L. Piso at Enna, 133 B.C., n. 1 (timeline only).

  • **Lewis and Short, *A Latin Dictionary* (1879), s.v. glans** (via https://lsj.gr/wiki/glans): "An acorn-shaped ball of lead or clay which was
  • hurled at the enemy". Supports the definition.

    Ancient texts (translations named; full excerpts in research/ancient-texts.md)

  • **Appian, Civil Wars 5.32 to 49**, tr. Horace White (Loeb 1913), LacusCurtius: https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Appian/Civil_Wars/5*.html
  • The siege works (5.33: ditch 30 feet deep and wide, 1,500 wooden towers, arms to the Tiber), the famine (5.35), the break-out with "stones,

    arrows, and leaden balls" (5.36; checked by us), the end (5.48 to 49: councillors executed, no sacrifice story). Appian wrote in the 2nd century A.D.

  • **Suetonius, Divus Augustus 14 to 15**, tr. J. C. Rolfe (Loeb), LacusCurtius; Latin, The Latin Library. Lucius was consul; Perusia forced to
  • surrender by hunger; "Scribunt quidam": 300 of both orders sacrificed on the Ides of March at the altar of the deified Julius.

  • **Cassius Dio 48.14**, tr. E. Cary (Loeb), LacusCurtius; Greek, Perseus. "The story goes": 300 knights and many senators sacrificed.
  • **Velleius Paterculus 2.74**, tr. F. W. Shipley (Loeb), LacusCurtius. Fulvia, Antony's wife, in arms; Perusia taken; cruelty blamed on the
  • soldiers; no sacrifice story. (Velleius says the town was stormed; the others say it surrendered from hunger. Noted in claims.md.)

  • **Martial 11.20**, Latin, The Latin Library: six verses Martial attributes to Augustus, about Fulvia. Our own translation of the first couplet.
  • **Bellum Africum 20**, tr. A. G. Way (Loeb 1955), LacusCurtius; Latin, The Latin Library: Caesar's army at Ruspina sets up smithies, casts
  • sling bullets ("glandes fundere") and asks Sicily for iron and lead. Location Ruspina checked by us (ch. 11 and 20).

  • **Vegetius, Epitoma rei militaris 3.14** (Latin, The Latin Library; our translation): slings of flax or horsehair ("has enim dicunt esse
  • meliores"); 2.23 whirl once round the head. Late 4th or 5th century A.D.

  • **Lucretius 6.177 to 179 and 6.306 to 307; Virgil, Aeneid 9.586 to 589; Ovid, Metamorphoses 2.727 to 729; Seneca, Natural Questions 2.57.2**
  • (Latin, The Latin Library; Leonard, Dryden, More, Clarke translations): the belief that a lead bullet heats up or melts in flight.

  • **Celsus, De Medicina 7.5.4**, tr. W. G. Spencer (Loeb 1938), LacusCurtius (checked by us): a lead bullet that has broken the skin and lodged
  • whole is extracted by widening the wound and drawing it out with forceps the way it entered.

  • **Ammianus Marcellinus 23.4.5 to 6**, tr. Rolfe: the onager's sling of hemp or iron (link to episode 2 only).
  • Excavation reports and museum records

  • **G. Jobey, "Burnswark Hill", Transactions of the Dumfriesshire and Galloway Natural History and Antiquarian Society 53 (1977 to 78) 57 to 104**,
  • https://dgnhas.org.uk/sites/default/files/transactions/3053.pdf (full text read by the research agent; key page checked against the image):

    133 lead bullets (54 by Jobey, 67 in 1898, 12 casual), "unique in this country"; weights 50 to 71 g; the rampart already denuded when the missiles

    fell; the "Command Battle School" conclusion and "some laxity in the retrieval of re-usable ammunition"; 20 and 12 bullets at the two south gateways

    in 1898.

  • **Christison, Barbour and Anderson, PSAS 33 (1899) 198 to 249** (the 1898 excavation; 67 glandes).
  • **J. H. Reid, "Bullets, ballistas, and Burnswark", Current Archaeology 316 (2016)**, https://www.archaeology.co.uk/articles/features/burnswark.htm
  • (read and checked by us): 130 bullets known before the project; small type I bullets "many weighing less than 20g" with a hole "approximately 5mm in

    diameter and about 5mm deep"; the buzz "eerily reminiscent of an agitated wasp"; psychological warfare as the simplest explanation; "nearly 700"

    lead targets; the barrage "along a full half kilometre of native rampart"; dating left open between the 120s and the late 130s in 2016.

  • **DGNHAS report of Reid's lecture, 2 December 2016**, https://dgnhas.org.uk/node/3453 (secondary summary of Reid): the 2015 trenches, 17 of 18 lead
  • targets Roman bullets; the hole 4 mm; the opening of the Antonine advance (Antonine Wall 142).

  • **J. H. Reid and A. Nicholson, "Burnswark Hill: the opening shot of the Antonine reconquest of Scotland?", JRA 32 (2019) 459 to 477**: abstract and
  • first page only ("exemplary force"; the question mark in the title; the camps north and south; the training-ground literature in n. 5).

  • **Portable Antiquities Scheme records** (via their Commons copies): PUBLIC-07BA1C (33.8 mm, 67.3 g), PUBLIC-640928 (97.8 g), PUBLIC-664DFF
  • (39.6 mm, 27.6 mm, 123.3 g) and nine more of the same group of twelve (lowest 67.3 g, highest 123.3 g), "probably mid-1st century", found together.

  • **Trimontium Trust photographs** (Commons): the drilled bullets, "an identical 4mm hole".
  • Modern scholarship and measurements

  • **T. Richardson, "The ballistics of the sling", Royal Armouries Yearbook 3 (1998) 44 to 49**, read in the copy at https://slinging.org/25.html
  • ("copied with permission"): velocities about 30 to 33 m/s; ranges with a replica of the Lahun sling (lead 40 g: 145 m average, 150 best; stones

    45 to 75 g: 90 m, 106 best); "I have not learned to sling within a sling-using culture ... or because I am inept ... Alternately, claims for the

    range of the sling may have been exaggerated"; "A good cast is usually accompanied by a whirring noise, from all types of projectile".

  • **Royal Society of Chemistry, periodic table, lead**: melting point 327.462 °C. https://periodic-table.rsc.org/element/82/lead
  • **Our calculation**: the stagnation temperature rise of air at speed v is v² / 2cp; with v = 30 m/s and cp = 1005 J/(kg K) this is about 0.45 K.
  • The bullet cannot be heated by the air above that temperature. (Labelled "our calculation" on screen.)

  • **J. C. Coulston, "The value of Trajan's Column as a source for military equipment" (BAR S476, 1989)**: slingers among the figure types; the column
  • is a sculptor's composition (caption only).

    Images (licences in image-manifest.json and in plan.CREDITS)

    Zangemeister's plates (public domain, 1885); Portable Antiquities Scheme photos (CC BY 2.0); Trimontium Trust photos (CC BY-SA 4.0); Geograph photos

    (CC BY-SA 2.0); Germanisches Nationalmuseum photo (W. Sauber, CC BY-SA 3.0); Cichorius plate XLVII of Trajan's Column (public domain); CNG photo of the

    41 B.C. denarius (CC BY-SA 2.5); PAS photo of Octavian's 42 B.C. denarius (CC BY 2.0); Perugia walls (CC BY-SA 3.0); Sertorian bullet (M. Calvo,

    Where the evidence is disputed, the article and the video say so. Reconstructions and replicas are labelled as such.

    Image credits

    • Slingers on Trajan's Column, A.D. 113 (scene LXVI). Plate by Conrad Cichorius, 1896. Public domain
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate IX 7 (L XI DIVOM IVLIVM, found at Perugia). Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate IX, Perusia. Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate VIII 6 (CAESAR IMP). Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Roman lead sling bullet, mid-1st century A.D., found in England. Portable Antiquities Scheme, PUBLIC-664DFF. Photo: Roger Thomas, CC BY 2.0
    • Lead sling bullet of the Sertorian War, 1st century B.C., Aragon. Photo: Miguel Calvo, CC BY-SA 4.0
    • Roman lead sling bullet, mid-1st century A.D., found in England. Portable Antiquities Scheme, PUBLIC-640928. Photo: Roger Thomas, CC BY 2.0
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate X 13 (ESVREIS ET ME CELAS). Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Roman lead sling bullet, mid-1st century A.D., found in England. Portable Antiquities Scheme, PUBLIC-07BA1C. Photo: Roger Thomas, CC BY 2.0
    • Perugia today: the town walls on the hill. Photo: Kurraudea, CC BY-SA 3.0
    • Denarius of Mark Antony and Octavian, 41 B.C., Ephesus mint. Photo: Classical Numismatic Group, CC BY-SA 2.5
    • Denarius of Octavian, 42 B.C., mint of Rome; head of Mars. Portable Antiquities Scheme. Photo: Alex Bliss, CC BY 2.0
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate X, Perusia. Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Photographs of the bullets: Zangemeister, Ephemeris Epigraphica VI (1885), plate VIII, Perusia. Public domain; scan Internet Archive
    • Lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill, Burnswark Project 2015 to 2017. Photo: John H. Reid, Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0
    • Roman lead sling bullets, one with a legion's name. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Nuremberg. Photo: Wolfgang Sauber, CC BY-SA 3.0
    • Burnswark Hill from the east: the hillfort on the summit, Roman camps to the south (left) and north (right). Photo: Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0
    • Burnswark Hill on the skyline, 2017. Photo: Richard Webb, CC BY-SA 2.0
    • Four drilled lead sling bullets from Burnswark Hill. Photo: Trimontium Trust, CC BY-SA 4.0
    • The south Roman camp and its mounds, Burnswark Hill. Photo: Lynne Kirton, CC BY-SA 2.0
    • Animations, maps and diagrams: original work, Spoken History. Map data: Natural Earth, public domain.
    • Music: Mendelssohn - String Quartet No. 6 in F minor, Op. 80 - III. Adagio (Musopen String Quartet): Felix Mendelssohn; released to the public domain by Musopen (PD-author on the Commons file page)
    • Music: Ludwig van Beethoven — Cello Sonata No. 3 (2nd movement): Ludwig van Beethoven; CC0 on the Commons file page
    • Music: Beethoven - String Quartet No. 6 in B flat major, Op. 18 No. 6 - II. Adagio, ma non troppo (Musopen String Quartet): Ludwig van Beethoven; released to the public domain by Musopen (PD-author on the Commons file page)
    • Music: Chopin - Cello Sonata in G minor, Op. 65 - III. Largo (Christopher Harding, Yeonjin Kim): Frédéric Chopin; released to the public domain by Musopen (PD-author on the Commons file page)
    • Music: NYCP Tchaikovsky Andante cantabile: Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, performed by New York Classical Players; CC-BY (YouTube CC-BY), credit required

    Transcript

    Read the full narration

    Roman Sling Bullets. Lead, insults, and a hill in Scotland. A lump of lead, about 4.5 centimetres long. It weighs 60 grams. On one side, a thunderbolt. On the other, raised letters: the number of a legion, the eleventh, and two words. DIVOM IVLIVM. The deified Julius. It was found at Perugia, in Italy. There, in the winter of 41 to 40 B.C., the young Octavian, the future Augustus, was starving out an army of his rivals. His side, scholars think, slung bullets like this one at the town. And this is one of the polite ones. Glandes. Roman sling bullets. We've taken apart a scorpion, an onager, a caltrop, a dagger, a sword and a suit of armour. The onager threw its stone from a sling. This time, the sling is in a soldier's hand. Today we're asking what these bullets were, what has been dug up, and what the texts really say. Because some of these little lumps of lead carry words. Messages, slung at the enemy. So, what is a glans? The Latin word means an acorn. The great Latin dictionary of Lewis and Short calls the missile an acorn-shaped ball of lead or clay, hurled at the enemy. Many Roman ones look more like an almond or a lemon, pointed at both ends. These, found together in England, weigh from about 67 to 123 grams. They were cast. Molten lead went into a two-part mould. Any letters were cut backwards into the mould, so they came out raised and readable on the bullet. And the army cast them itself. In Africa, in 46 B.C., the unknown author of the African War writes that Caesar's army set up smithies, cast sling bullets, and sent to Sicily for lead. The weapon that threw them was simple. Two cords and a pouch. The late Roman writer Vegetius says slings were made of flax or of hair. Back to Perugia. Ancient Perusia, a town on a hill in Etruria. In 41 B.C., Mark Antony's brother Lucius, who was consul that year, and Antony's wife Fulvia took up arms against Octavian. Lucius ended up shut inside Perusia. The historian Appian, writing nearly two centuries later, says Octavian ringed the hill with a ditch 30 feet deep and 30 wide, and a wall with 1,500 wooden towers. Inside, the food ran out. Appian says the slaves were refused rations and ate grass, and the dead were buried in long trenches, so the enemy would not see how many there were. When the besieged tried to break out, he says, they fought from their siege towers with stones, arrows, and leaden balls. And the bullets from that siege talk back. In 1885, the German scholar Karl Zangemeister published the inscribed Latin sling bullets known in his day. Perusia has its own chapter, and its own photographic plates. Most, he argued, came from Octavian's side. Some carry a commander: CAESAR IMP, Caesar, general. That is Octavian, who used his adoptive father's name. Some name a legion and an officer. L XII. SCAEVA PR PIL: legion 12, Scaeva, chief centurion. And some carry a message. One reads: ESVREIS ET ME CELAS. You're starving, and you're hiding it from me. Another was scratched by hand into the finished bullet. Bald Lucius Antonius, you're done for, by Gaius Caesar's victory. Then there are the ones I can't read out. One aims at Fulvia's body. One, from Lucius's side, aims at Octavian's backside. Parts of those words are modern restorations, but the meaning is plain. And it wasn't only the soldiers. The poet Martial, more than a century later, quotes six verses that he says Augustus himself wrote about Fulvia. They are just as crude. If you are enjoying this type of content, please don't forget to subscribe. Perusia gave in to hunger early in 40 B.C. Then comes the darkest story. Suetonius writes that some say three hundred prisoners were picked out and sacrificed, on the Ides of March, at an altar to the deified Julius. Cassius Dio tells it too, as a story that goes around. Appian and Velleius, who both describe the end of the siege, don't mention it. Zangemeister linked the eleventh legion's bullet, DIVOM IVLIVM, to that story. But the bullet only names the legion and the god. Whether it called for revenge, and whether the sacrifice happened at all, we don't know. There's a catch with inscribed bullets. Collectors wanted them. And where there's a market, there's a forger. From about 1860, a man in Ascoli, Giuseppe Vincenzini, took genuine, blank ancient bullets and hammered them into carved wooden dies, putting new words into old lead. A French scholar published more than 600 of them as genuine. In 1877, Vincenzini confessed to Zangemeister, in front of two witnesses. Zangemeister also records a boast. Vincenzini once bought an inscribed bullet from a countryman, sure it was ancient. Later he realised the inscription was his own work. How do you tell? A real inscription was cast with the bullet. The forger's letters were struck into lead that had already corroded, with sharp edges and angular round letters. And real bullets were mostly blank. At Ascoli, besieged by Rome in the Social War, Zangemeister and a local colleague dug for three days in 1877. 238 bullets. 2 had writing. So how good was a lead bullet? The Romans had an odd idea about that. Lucretius, Virgil, Ovid and Seneca all write that a lead bullet heats up in flight. Some say it melts. It doesn't. In tests for the Royal Armouries in the 1990s, Thom Richardson measured slung bullets at about 30 metres a second. At that speed, by our own calculation, the air warms the lead by less than 1 degree. Lead melts at about 327 °C. What lead did do was fly further. In the same tests, 40-gram lead bullets went about 145 metres on average. Stones, about 80 to 90. Richardson himself warns that he never learned the sling in a culture that used it. Skilled slingers may have done better. Or the old claims of range may be exaggerated. And when one hit? The Roman writer Celsus, in the first century A.D., explains what to do with a lead bullet that has broken the skin and lodged inside. Open the wound wider, he says, and draw it out with forceps, the way it went in. Now, a hill in Scotland. Burnswark, in Dumfriesshire, north of the line of Hadrian's Wall. A flat-topped hill, ringed by the ramparts of an Iron Age fort. And on its slopes, two Roman camps. One to the south, one to the north. In 1898, excavators found 67 lead sling bullets here. 20 lay at one gateway of the hillfort, 12 at another. By the 1970s the count stood at 133. The archaeologist George Jobey called that unique in Britain. More recently, a team led by John Reid swept the hill with metal detectors. They found nearly 700 more signals that looked like lead sling bullets, most of them along the southern rampart. Reid traces the barrage along about half a kilometre of it. In two test trenches in 2015, 17 of the 18 lead signals turned out to be Roman bullets. Some of the bullets are small, many under 20 grams, with a hole drilled about 5 millimetres wide. When the team slung copies, they buzzed in flight, Reid writes, like an agitated wasp. He thinks they were meant to frighten. That's his team's hypothesis. And Richardson notes that a good cast whirrs anyway, with any kind of missile. So what happened at Burnswark? The early excavators saw a siege. In 1978, George Jobey argued for a training ground. A field school, where the army practised building camps and attacking with slings, bows and artillery. A key point: the rampart was already ruined when the bullets fell. Reid's team confirmed that. Jobey had one quibble with his own theory. There was, he wrote, some laxity in the retrieval of re-usable ammunition. Reid and his colleague Andrew Nicholson read it the other way. A barrage this big looks to them like a real assault, a show of force, perhaps at the start of the Roman advance into Scotland around A.D. 140. The title of their own paper ends with a question mark. Siege or firing range? The evidence has not settled it. So, what do we really have? Thousands of real bullets, most of them blank. A small share with words: commanders, legions, jokes and threats. Texts that say the army cast them, surgeons cut them out, and poets thought they melted. What we don't have: how many Roman soldiers carried a sling, or the full story of what happened at Burnswark. So that's the Roman sling bullet. A lump of lead you could close your hand around. And now and then, a message. Three questions for you. Burnswark: a real assault, or a firing range with sloppy clean-up? The drilled bullets: made to frighten, or is the buzz just a side effect? And what should I take apart next? The Roman helmets, or the scutum? Thanks for watching, and I'll see you in the next one. It's on your screen right now. Tap it, and I'll see you there.

    All 27 topics

    Roman Sling Bullets · Sling Bullet · Glandes · Glans · Lead Sling Bullet · Roman Slingers · Funditores · Perusia · Perusine War · Siege of Perusia · Octavian · Fulvia · Lucius Antonius · Burnswark · Burnswark Hill · Whistling Sling Bullets · Zangemeister · Asculum · Roman Forgeries · Celsus · Appian · Roman Army · Roman Military Equipment · Ancient Weapons · Roman History · Roman Archaeology · Roman Britain

    More episodes