Spoken HistoryReal history. Real evidence.

Autumn, 331 B.C. A plain in what is now northern Iraq. Two armies are about to meet. Then a deserter comes running across the ground to Alexander the Great. His news, according to the Roman writer Quintus Curtius: the Persian king, Darius, has buried iron spikes in the earth, right where he expects the Macedonian cavalry to charge. And the spot is marked with a sign, so the Persians know where not to ride.

Animation: Gaugamela and Arbela in northern Iraq. The exact site of the battle is uncertain.
Animation: Gaugamela and Arbela in northern Iraq. The exact site of the battle is uncertain.Original animation, Spoken History. Map data (where shown): Natural Earth, public domain
Animation: Curtius' account as a diagram. Not confirmed by Arrian or Diodorus. Positions are schematic.
Animation: Curtius' account as a diagram. Not confirmed by Arrian or Diodorus. Positions are schematic.Original animation, Spoken History

Caltrops. A few centimetres of iron, with four spikes. If you've seen our scorpion and onager videos, this is the opposite. No spring. No crew. No skill needed. Today we're taking one apart. What it is. What the Romans called it. What has actually been dug up. And how much of the famous stories we can trust. Because the evidence, as usual, is thinner than the legend.

A Roman iron caltrop in the Westphalian Museum of Archaeology, Herne.
A Roman iron caltrop in the Westphalian Museum of Archaeology, Herne.A Roman iron caltrop, Westphalian Museum of Archaeology, Herne. Photo: Bullenwaechter, CC BY-SA 3.0
A Roman-period caltrop in the Israel Museum, Jerusalem.
A Roman-period caltrop in the Israel Museum, Jerusalem.A Roman-period caltrop, Israel Museum, Jerusalem. Photo: Gary Todd, CC0

What is a caltrop?

So, what is a caltrop? A small iron object with four sharp points, arranged so that, whichever way it lands, three points rest on the ground, and the fourth stands up. The Roman writer Vegetius describes exactly that. However you throw it, he says, it stands on three rays, and the fourth is upright, and hostile. It isn't a clever design. It's a geometry trick. Four points, spaced like the corners of a pyramid, so it can't lie flat. And it's small. The Roman ones from the fort at Tyras, on the Black Sea, are about five centimetres across.

Animation: however it lands, three points rest on the ground and one stands up. An ideal four-spike shape; real finds are irregular.
Animation: however it lands, three points rest on the ground and one stands up. An ideal four-spike shape; real finds are irregular.Original animation, Spoken History
Animation: the size reported for the caltrops from Tyras, about five centimetres. Shape idealised.
Animation: the size reported for the caltrops from Tyras, about five centimetres. Shape idealised.Original animation, Spoken History

What the Romans called it

Now, the names. The Romans called it a tribulus. The word is borrowed from Greek, where tribolos was also the name of a spiny plant. Botanists still call the caltrop plant Tribulus. Latin has another word, murex, which is also a spiny shellfish. Curtius uses it for the spikes at Gaugamela. So does another Roman writer, Valerius Maximus. And the English word, caltrop? Dictionaries trace it through medieval Latin, to words for treading, and for a trap. Careful, though. Vegetius also uses tribulus for the wooden stakes of a camp's palisade. Same word, different thing.

Animation: the Greek tribolos, the Latin tribulus, and the plant.
Animation: the Greek tribolos, the Latin tribulus, and the plant.Original animation, Spoken History
Tribulus terrestris, the caltrop plant, which shares the Greek name.
Tribulus terrestris, the caltrop plant, which shares the Greek name.Tribulus terrestris, the caltrop plant. Photo: Harry Rose, CC BY 2.0
Animation: Latin murex, the spiny shellfish, and the English word.
Animation: Latin murex, the spiny shellfish, and the English word.Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? The Greek word tribolos, and the Latin tribulus, named a spiny plant as well as the weapon. Botanists still call the caltrop plant Tribulus.

Did Darius bury them? Curtius against Arrian

Back to Gaugamela, and that deserter. In Curtius, Alexander calls his officers together, tells them where the marked ground is, and warns the cavalry to keep away from it. It's a good story. It might even be true. But look at who tells it. Arrian, who draws on officers who were there, says only that Alexander's general Parmenio wanted the ground checked first, for hidden ditches and stakes. No caltrops. No deserter. Diodorus, in his long account of the battle, has no spikes at all. So buried caltrops at Gaugamela come from one writer, more than three centuries after the battle. Possible. Not proven.

Animation: who says what about buried caltrops at Gaugamela.
Animation: who says what about buried caltrops at Gaugamela.Original animation, Spoken History

Vegetius and the scythed chariots

The best-known Roman story is about chariots. Some armies fitted their chariots with scythe blades. Vegetius says they terrified at first, then became a joke. They need flat ground, and one wounded horse can stop them. But they perished most, he writes, to a trick of Roman soldiers. When battle was joined, the Romans suddenly threw caltrops across the whole field. The chariots ran onto them, and were destroyed. Vegetius names no battle, no commander, no date. He wrote in the late empire, about an older army. So this tells us what a Roman writer thought caltrops were for. Not what happened on a particular field.

Animation: Vegetius 3.24 as a diagram. He names no battle. Positions are schematic.
Animation: Vegetius 3.24 as a diagram. He names no battle. Positions are schematic.Original animation, Spoken History
Vegetius, De re militari, in a 15th-century Italian manuscript.
Vegetius, De re militari, in a 15th-century Italian manuscript.Vegetius, De re militari, 15th-century Italian manuscript. Boston Public Library, public domain

The general who refused them

Here's a different Roman story, and I like it better. Valerius Maximus tells of Scipio Aemilianus, besieging a very strong city. His advisers suggest scattering iron spikes around its walls, so the besieged can't rush out. Scipio answers that it doesn't belong to the same man to want to capture people, and to be afraid. It's a story about courage, told to praise him. But look at what it takes for granted: that caltrops were a familiar idea, and that a proud commander might see them as a sign of fear.

Animation: Valerius Maximus 3.7.2 as a diagram. He does not name the city.
Animation: Valerius Maximus 3.7.2 as a diagram. He does not name the city.Original animation, Spoken History

Did you know? In Valerius Maximus' story, Scipio Aemilianus is advised to scatter iron spikes around a besieged city. He answers that it does not belong to the same man to want to capture people, and to be afraid.

What archaeology has found

So what has actually been dug up? Iron caltrops, four-pronged, turn up in Roman military sites across the empire. A recent study from Tyras lists finds in Gaul, Dacia, Germany, Austria, Croatia and Britain. At Caerleon, in Wales, seventeen were found at the site of the legionary barracks, fourteen of them in one room. They're third century. More at Newstead, in Scotland. At Enns, on the Danube. And at Tyras, in a building that one excavator thought might have been an arsenal. In the reports we read, the finds come in handfuls. We don't know how many an army carried.

The Prysg Field barracks at Caerleon today, where seventeen caltrops were found.
The Prysg Field barracks at Caerleon today, where seventeen caltrops were found.The Prysg Field barracks at Caerleon today. Photo: Otter, CC BY-SA 4.0
Animation: seventeen caltrops, fourteen in one room. Schematic; real find spots are not shown.
Animation: seventeen caltrops, fourteen in one room. Schematic; real find spots are not shown.Original animation, Spoken History
Animation: a few of the sites. Not a complete list.
Animation: a few of the sites. Not a complete list.Original animation, Spoken History. Map data (where shown): Natural Earth, public domain

Did you know? At Caerleon in Wales, seventeen caltrops were found at the site of the legionary barracks, and fourteen of them lay in one room. They are third century.

A label from Enns

Here are some from the Roman museum at Enns, in Austria. Second to fourth century. The museum's own label says they were mostly an obstacle to stop an approach. Thrown down, they always land with one point up. Not one is a work of art. Rough iron, small enough to carry by the handful.

Caltrops in the Roman Museum, Enns.
Caltrops in the Roman Museum, Enns.Caltrops in the Roman Museum, Enns. Photo: Dguendel, CC BY 4.0
An iron caltrop in the Yale University Art Gallery, for comparison.
An iron caltrop in the Yale University Art Gallery, for comparison.An iron caltrop, Yale University Art Gallery (1938.5999.77), CC0

How were they used?

How were they used? Here the evidence runs thin. Against horses and chariots, in Curtius and Vegetius. As an obstacle on an approach, on the museum's reading. Buried with a point showing, or thrown onto the surface. Everything else is guesswork. How they were carried. Who laid them. Whether they were collected again. We don't know.

Animation: how they were used, and what the sources support.
Animation: how they were used, and what the sources support.Original animation, Spoken History

Three myths

Three myths. One. Caesar used caltrops at Alesia. Not in his own account. What he describes buried across the ground are foot-long logs with iron hooks in them. He calls them stimuli. Spurs. A different object, a similar idea. Two. Caltrops won battles. In the texts we've read, they stop chariots and horses. None says they decided a battle. Three. It was a Roman invention. Not at all. Iron caltrops sit in museums in Korea and Inner Mongolia too, and the Latin word was borrowed from Greek.

Animation: three myths, and what the texts really say.
Animation: three myths, and what the texts really say.Original animation, Spoken History

What we really have

So, what do we really have? Real objects. Four-pointed iron, about five centimetres, from Roman military sites in several provinces. A few Roman texts. One definition. A chariot story. A buried-iron story from Alexander's war. And a commander who said no. What we don't have: numbers, a battle where we can see them at work, or an eyewitness account of one doing its job.

Animation: what the evidence gives us, and what we do not have.
Animation: what the evidence gives us, and what we do not have.Original animation, Spoken History

Verdict, and what comes next

So that's the caltrop. One of the smallest weapons we've looked at on this channel. And one of the oldest ideas. Make the ground itself dangerous. Next up is another small piece of Roman iron. The dagger. The pugio.

Over to you

Would you have scattered them, or answered like Scipio? What next after the pugio: the gladius or the segmented armour?

Prefer to watch? The video on YouTube covers the same story with the full animations. Jump to a part:

  • 0:00 A deserter at Gaugamela, 331 B.C.
  • 1:08 What is a caltrop?
  • 1:47 What the Romans called it
  • 2:31 Did Darius bury them? Curtius against Arrian
  • 3:17 Vegetius and the scythed chariots
  • 4:00 The general who refused them
  • 4:39 What archaeology has found
  • 5:21 A label from Enns
  • 5:43 How were they used?
  • 6:08 Three myths
  • 6:51 What we really have
  • 7:20 Verdict, and what comes next

Quick answers

What is a caltrop?

A small iron object with four sharp points arranged like the corners of a pyramid, so that however it lands, three points rest on the ground and the fourth stands up. Roman examples from Tyras are about five centimetres across.

What did the Romans call a caltrop?

Tribulus, a word borrowed from the Greek tribolos, which also named a spiny plant. Latin also has murex, a spiny shellfish, which Curtius uses for the spikes at Gaugamela.

Did Darius bury caltrops at Gaugamela?

Only Curtius, writing more than three centuries after the battle, says so. Arrian and Diodorus do not mention caltrops. It is possible, but not proven.

Did Caesar use caltrops at Alesia?

Not in his own account. He describes foot-long logs with iron hooks buried across the ground, which he calls stimuli, or spurs: a different object, a similar idea.

What have archaeologists found?

Four-pronged iron caltrops turn up at Roman military sites in Gaul, Dacia, Germany, Austria, Croatia and Britain. At Caerleon in Wales, seventeen were found at the legionary barracks, fourteen of them in one room.

Where it happened

  • Gaugamela (northern Iraq) (331 B.C.): Where Curtius says Darius buried iron spikes. The exact site of the battle is uncertain.
  • Caerleon (Wales) (A.D. 250): Seventeen caltrops, fourteen of them in one room of the legionary barracks. Third century.
  • Newstead (Scotland) (A.D. 150): A caltrop from the Roman fort, 1st and 2nd centuries.
  • Enns (Austria) (A.D. 250): Caltrops in the Roman museum, 2nd to 4th century.
  • Tyras (Bilhorod-Dnistrovskyi, Ukraine) (A.D. 200): Caltrops about 5 cm across from a building thought by one excavator to be an arsenal.

Sources

Ancient writers and modern work

Ancient writers (Latin read directly from thelatinlibrary.com on 2026-11-12; translations are our own; Arrian read in the 1893 Chinnock translation on Project Gutenberg, Diodorus in Loeb/LacusCurtius)

  • Vegetius, Epitoma rei militaris 3.24 (scythed chariots "delighted" the Romans' enemy at first, then were mocked; Romans scattered "tribuli" over the whole field and the chariots were destroyed on them; his definition: "a tribulus is a defence fixed together from four stakes, which stands on three rays however you throw it, and with the fourth upright is hostile") and 3.8 ("valli, hoc est tribuli lignei": in the camp-rampart passage he calls the wooden stakes of the palisade "tribuli lignei"). Late (c. A.D. 390 to 450), describing an idealised older army: the Latin word names a caltrop in 3.24 and wooden stakes in 3.8. No battle is named in 3.24.
  • Quintus Curtius Rufus, Historiae Alexandri Magni 4.13.36 (Gaugamela, 331 B.C.): a deserter called Bion tells Alexander that Darius has buried "murices ferreos" (iron "murices") where he expected the cavalry to charge, the place marked by a sign; Alexander tells his officers to avoid the marked ground. Curtius is a Roman writer of the 1st century A.D. (exact date disputed), writing about 350 years after the battle. He uses "murex", not "tribulus".
  • Arrian, Anabasis 3.9 (Gaugamela): Parmenio proposes to reconnoitre the ground first "to see if there were ditches or stakes firmly fixed in the earth out of sight"; Alexander rides round the field. No caltrops, iron spikes or deserter named Bion. Diodorus Siculus 17.53 to 17.61 (the battle "near Arbela"): read in full, no caltrops or iron spikes. So the buried caltrops and Bion appear in Curtius alone, among the surviving full accounts of Gaugamela.
  • Valerius Maximus, Facta et dicta memorabilia 3.7.2 (written under Tiberius): Scipio Aemilianus, besieging a very strong city, is advised "ferreos murices spargeret" around its walls and cover every ford with lead plates studded with nail points so the enemy cannot sally out; he answers that it does not belong to the same man to want to capture people and to be afraid. City not named by Valerius. A story told to show Scipio's confidence, not evidence of what was done.
  • Smith's Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities (1875), s.v. Tribulus (J. Yates): tribulus (Greek tribolos) = caltrop, "also called murex" (Val. Max. 3.7.2; Curt. 4.13.36); thrown so that one point is upward, or buried with one point at the surface (Veget. 3.24; Julius Africanus, Kestoi 69); also Procopius, Gothic War 3.24.16 ff. Procopius and Africanus were NOT read for this episode.
  • Caesar, Gallic War 7.73 (Alesia): "stimuli" are logs with iron hooks buried in the ground, not caltrops. Mentioned only to clear a common mix-up.
  • Archaeology and museums

  • Oleh Saveliev, "Roman Military Equipment from Tyras", Cercetari Arheologice 32(2), 2025 (open access PDF, read): several iron four-pronged caltrops from the fill of the "vexillation building" at Tyras (Black Sea, Moesia Inferior), about 5 x 5 cm, some slightly larger; "When thrown onto the ground, they would rest on three prongs, leaving the fourth pointing upward"; parallels at several sites in Gaul and southern Dacia, Augsburg-Oberhausen, Siscia, Mogorella, Newstead, Haltern, Carnuntum, York, Corbridge, Enns-Lauriacum and the National Museum of Wales. Abstract: parallels in Roman military camps of the 2nd to first half of the 3rd century A.D. along the Upper German-Raetian and Danubian limes, in Britain, Syria and the Northern Black Sea. Cites Curle 1911 pl. XXXVIII (Newstead), Flügel 2010, Filip 2023, Chapman 2005, James 2004 (Dura-Europos), Radman-Livaja 2004. We have NOT read those; the list of sites is Saveliev's.
  • Museum Wales (Amgueddfa Cymru) collections record, Caerleon (Isca) iron caltrops: 17 from Prysg Field, 14 in one room, 3rd century A.D. (our notes of the online record, 2026-11-12). Text only; no museum image is used (no open licence).
  • National Museums Scotland, Newstead (Trimontium) iron caltrop (record X.FRA 224), Roman fort of the 1st and 2nd centuries. Text only; no image used.
  • Roman Museum Enns (Austria), display label (photograph on Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0, by Dguendel): "Fussangeln | triboli, 2. bis 4. Jh., Eisen, Fundort Enns und Enns/Legionslager. Sie dienten vorwiegend als Annaherungshindernis. Wenn sie geworfen wurden, landeten sie immer so, dass ein Stachel nach oben zeigt." The label is the museum's own modern statement.
  • Photographs used, all with licence on screen: Herne (Westphalian Museum of Archaeology) iron Roman caltrop, CC BY-SA 3.0, Bullenwachter; Enns label photo, CC BY 4.0, Dguendel; Israel Museum Jerusalem "Caltrop, unprovenanced, Roman period, iron", CC0, Gary Todd; Yale University Art Gallery 1938.5999.77 iron caltrop from Dura-Europos excavations, CC0.
  • Bibliography we could not open: C. Fluegel, "Tribuli - Roemische Kraehenfuesse", Bayerische Vorgeschichtsblaetter 75 (2010) 143-146; G. Filip, "Caltrops (tribuli) from Southern Dacia", in A. Barbulescu (ed.), Roman Dacia and the Roman army (2023) 87-92; E. M. Chapman, A Catalogue of Roman Military Equipment in the National Museum of Wales, BAR 388 (2005); S. James, The Excavations at Dura-Europos: the Arms and Armour and other Military Equipment (2004).
  • Words

  • Latin tribulus is borrowed from Greek tribolos (secondary: Wiktionary, citing Lewis and Short). It names the caltrop and also a prickly plant (Tribulus terrestris, the "caltrop plant"). Latin "murex" is also "a caltrop, an iron spike" (Lewis and Short) as well as the spiny purple-dye shellfish. English "caltrop": Old English calcatrippe, from Medieval Latin calcatrippa, built from calx (heel) or calcare (to tread) plus trappa (trap) (Wiktionary, secondary; the OED not consulted). The video says only "a word that means something like 'foot trap'".
  • Where the evidence is disputed, the article and the video say so. Reconstructions and replicas are labelled as such.

    Image credits

    • The Prysg Field barracks at Caerleon today. Photo: Otter, CC BY-SA 4.0
    • A Roman iron caltrop, Westphalian Museum of Archaeology, Herne. Photo: Bullenwaechter, CC BY-SA 3.0
    • A Roman-period caltrop, Israel Museum, Jerusalem. Photo: Gary Todd, CC0
    • Tribulus terrestris, the caltrop plant. Photo: Harry Rose, CC BY 2.0
    • Vegetius, De re militari, 15th-century Italian manuscript. Boston Public Library, public domain
    • An iron caltrop, Yale University Art Gallery (1938.5999.77), CC0
    • Caltrops in the Roman Museum, Enns. Photo: Dguendel, CC BY 4.0
    • Animations, maps and diagrams: original work, Spoken History. Map data: Natural Earth, public domain.

    Transcript

    Read the full narration

    What Is a Caltrop?. Rome's four-spiked iron, and its myths. Autumn, 331 B.C. A plain in what is now northern Iraq. Two armies are about to meet. Then a deserter comes running across the ground to Alexander the Great. His news, according to the Roman writer Quintus Curtius: the Persian king, Darius, has buried iron spikes in the earth, right where he expects the Macedonian cavalry to charge. And the spot is marked with a sign, so the Persians know where not to ride. Caltrops. A few centimetres of iron, with four spikes. If you've seen our scorpion and onager videos, this is the opposite. No spring. No crew. No skill needed. Today we're taking one apart. What it is. What the Romans called it. What has actually been dug up. And how much of the famous stories we can trust. Because the evidence, as usual, is thinner than the legend. So, what is a caltrop? A small iron object with four sharp points, arranged so that, whichever way it lands, three points rest on the ground, and the fourth stands up. The Roman writer Vegetius describes exactly that. However you throw it, he says, it stands on three rays, and the fourth is upright, and hostile. It isn't a clever design. It's a geometry trick. Four points, spaced like the corners of a pyramid, so it can't lie flat. And it's small. The Roman ones from the fort at Tyras, on the Black Sea, are about five centimetres across. Now, the names. The Romans called it a tribulus. The word is borrowed from Greek, where tribolos was also the name of a spiny plant. Botanists still call the caltrop plant Tribulus. Latin has another word, murex, which is also a spiny shellfish. Curtius uses it for the spikes at Gaugamela. So does another Roman writer, Valerius Maximus. And the English word, caltrop? Dictionaries trace it through medieval Latin, to words for treading, and for a trap. Careful, though. Vegetius also uses tribulus for the wooden stakes of a camp's palisade. Same word, different thing. Back to Gaugamela, and that deserter. In Curtius, Alexander calls his officers together, tells them where the marked ground is, and warns the cavalry to keep away from it. It's a good story. It might even be true. But look at who tells it. Arrian, who draws on officers who were there, says only that Alexander's general Parmenio wanted the ground checked first, for hidden ditches and stakes. No caltrops. No deserter. Diodorus, in his long account of the battle, has no spikes at all. So buried caltrops at Gaugamela come from one writer, more than three centuries after the battle. Possible. Not proven. The best-known Roman story is about chariots. Some armies fitted their chariots with scythe blades. Vegetius says they terrified at first, then became a joke. They need flat ground, and one wounded horse can stop them. But they perished most, he writes, to a trick of Roman soldiers. When battle was joined, the Romans suddenly threw caltrops across the whole field. The chariots ran onto them, and were destroyed. Vegetius names no battle, no commander, no date. He wrote in the late empire, about an older army. So this tells us what a Roman writer thought caltrops were for. Not what happened on a particular field. Here's a different Roman story, and I like it better. Valerius Maximus tells of Scipio Aemilianus, besieging a very strong city. His advisers suggest scattering iron spikes around its walls, so the besieged can't rush out. Scipio answers that it doesn't belong to the same man to want to capture people, and to be afraid. It's a story about courage, told to praise him. But look at what it takes for granted: that caltrops were a familiar idea, and that a proud commander might see them as a sign of fear. If you are enjoying this type of content, please don't forget to subscribe. So what has actually been dug up? Iron caltrops, four-pronged, turn up in Roman military sites across the empire. A recent study from Tyras lists finds in Gaul, Dacia, Germany, Austria, Croatia and Britain. At Caerleon, in Wales, seventeen were found at the site of the legionary barracks, fourteen of them in one room. They're third century. More at Newstead, in Scotland. At Enns, on the Danube. And at Tyras, in a building that one excavator thought might have been an arsenal. In the reports we read, the finds come in handfuls. We don't know how many an army carried. Here are some from the Roman museum at Enns, in Austria. Second to fourth century. The museum's own label says they were mostly an obstacle to stop an approach. Thrown down, they always land with one point up. Not one is a work of art. Rough iron, small enough to carry by the handful. How were they used? Here the evidence runs thin. Against horses and chariots, in Curtius and Vegetius. As an obstacle on an approach, on the museum's reading. Buried with a point showing, or thrown onto the surface. Everything else is guesswork. How they were carried. Who laid them. Whether they were collected again. We don't know. Three myths. One. Caesar used caltrops at Alesia. Not in his own account. What he describes buried across the ground are foot-long logs with iron hooks in them. He calls them stimuli. Spurs. A different object, a similar idea. Two. Caltrops won battles. In the texts we've read, they stop chariots and horses. None says they decided a battle. Three. It was a Roman invention. Not at all. Iron caltrops sit in museums in Korea and Inner Mongolia too, and the Latin word was borrowed from Greek. So, what do we really have? Real objects. Four-pointed iron, about five centimetres, from Roman military sites in several provinces. A few Roman texts. One definition. A chariot story. A buried-iron story from Alexander's war. And a commander who said no. What we don't have: numbers, a battle where we can see them at work, or an eyewitness account of one doing its job. So that's the caltrop. One of the smallest weapons we've looked at on this channel. And one of the oldest ideas. Make the ground itself dangerous. Two questions for you. If you were a Roman commander, would you have scattered them, or answered like Scipio? And after the pugio, what should I take apart next? The gladius, or the segmented armour, the lorica segmentata? Next up is another small piece of Roman iron. The dagger. The pugio. It's on your screen right now. Tap it, and I'll see you there.

    All 16 topics

    Caltrop · Roman Caltrop · What Is a Caltrop · Tribulus · Roman Army · Vegetius · Curtius · Gaugamela · Alexander the Great · Caerleon · Ancient Weapons · Roman Military Equipment · How It Worked · Ancient History · Roman History · Roman Archaeology

    More episodes